Government & Spending

The Average 401(k) Has $167,970 — the 4% Rule Provides $560 a Month, While Social Security Pays $2,081

The Average 401(k) Has $167,970 — the 4% Rule Provides $560 a Month, While Social Security Pays $2,081

Three figures help explain the reality of retirement finances in the United States. The average 401(k) balance stands at $167,970, while the traditional 4% withdrawal rule would turn that amount into only about $560 per month during the first year of retirement.

Meanwhile, the average Social Security retirement benefit is approximately $2,081 per month, according to the Social Security Administration.

For many Americans, this means Social Security provides the foundation of retirement income, while workplace savings such as a 401(k) serve as additional financial support.

Why the Average 401(k) Balance Can Be Misleading

Vanguard’s How America Saves 2026 report shows that participants had an average account balance of $167,970 in 2025, while the median balance was significantly lower at $44,115.

Compared with the previous year, the average increased by 13% and the median rose by 16%, helped by a 19.3% one-year participant return.

The difference between the average and median is important. An average is calculated by adding all account balances and dividing by the number of accounts. The median represents the midpoint, meaning half of participants have more money and half have less.

Large retirement accounts can push the average considerably higher. Vanguard notes that the average balance is roughly equivalent to the 75th percentile, suggesting about three-quarters of participants have balances below the headline average.

Around 26% of accounts contain less than $10,000, while only 35% have more than $100,000. At the higher end, approximately 18% hold $250,000 or more.

Age Also Changes the Retirement Savings Picture

Overall 401(k) averages combine workers at very different stages of their careers. A 25-year-old who recently started contributing is included alongside someone approaching retirement at age 60.

Vanguard notes that larger average balances are often associated with older, higher-income or longer-tenured workers.

For retirement planning, balances among people nearing retirement are therefore more meaningful than a single average covering every age group.

Defined contribution accounts such as 401(k) and 403(b) plans ultimately depend on how much workers contribute, employer contributions where available, investment performance and the amount of time money remains invested.

What Does the 4% Retirement Rule Mean?

The widely used 4% rule originated from research published in 1994 by financial planner William Bengen.

Bengen examined historical US market returns to determine how much retirees could withdraw during their first year of retirement and then increase withdrawals with inflation while attempting to avoid exhausting their savings over a 30-year retirement period.

His analysis generally assumed portfolios containing approximately 50% to 75% stocks, with the remainder invested in bonds. Taxes and investment fees were not included.

Researchers, including Bengen, have since considered different withdrawal rates depending on factors such as market valuations, bond yields and retirement length.

The 4% rule should therefore be treated as a planning guideline rather than a guarantee.

What $167,970 Provides Under the 4% Rule

Applying a 4% first-year withdrawal rate to a $167,970 portfolio produces about $6,719 annually, or approximately $560 per month, before considering taxes and future inflation adjustments.

Retirees must also consider sequence-of-returns risk. A major market decline during the first few years of retirement can have a greater long-term effect because withdrawals reduce the amount of money available to recover when markets eventually rebound.

Social Security Provides More Income for Many Retirees

The Social Security Administration reports that the average retired worker receives approximately $2,081 per month.

That amount is substantially higher than the monthly income generated by the average 401(k) balance under the 4% guideline.

The difference becomes even greater when using Vanguard’s median balance of $44,115. A 4% withdrawal from that amount would provide only about $1,765 annually, or roughly $147 per month during the first year.

The 2027 Social Security cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) is currently tracking around 3.1%, based on one of the three third-quarter inflation readings used to determine the annual adjustment.

These figures highlight why Social Security remains the primary retirement income source for many households, with private retirement savings functioning as a supplement.

Retirement Expenses Can Still Exceed Available Income

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported average annual household expenditures of $78,535 in 2024.

Neither Social Security nor typical workplace retirement savings would independently provide enough income to match spending at that level.

Retirees may therefore need to combine Social Security, retirement accounts, pensions, personal savings and other income sources depending on their circumstances.

Three Retirement Decisions That Can Matter More Than Fund Selection

1. Choosing When to Claim Social Security

Waiting to claim Social Security after reaching full retirement age permanently increases the monthly benefit until age 70.

Because Social Security benefits continue for life and receive inflation adjustments, the claiming decision can significantly affect lifetime retirement income.

2. Considering Survivor Benefits

For married couples, the higher earner’s Social Security claiming decision can also influence the benefit available to a surviving spouse.

Claiming benefits early may reduce the amount eventually available to the survivor, potentially affecting their income for many years.

3. Understanding Taxes on 401(k) Withdrawals

Withdrawals from a traditional 401(k) are generally treated as ordinary taxable income. As a result, retirees may have less available to spend than the gross withdrawal amount suggests.

Traditional retirement-account withdrawals can also contribute to provisional income calculations, potentially causing part of Social Security benefits to become taxable.

The headline average 401(k) balance of $167,970 may appear encouraging, but it does not represent what most workers actually have saved. The median balance of $44,115 provides a more realistic picture for many Americans.

When typical retirement savings are compared with the approximately $2,081 average monthly Social Security benefit, it becomes clear that Social Security is likely to remain the core source of retirement income for millions of retirees.

Understanding withdrawal rates, Social Security claiming strategies, survivor benefits and taxes can therefore be just as important as choosing investments when preparing for retirement.

Merci