Labor Plans Social Media Algorithm Crackdown as Taylor Says He’s ‘Deeply Sceptical’
Labor’s proposed crackdown on social media algorithms is facing strong resistance in federal parliament, with Opposition Leader Angus Taylor raising concerns that the new rules could lead to government censorship of online speech.
Communications Minister Anika Wells is expected to release draft legislation for a new digital duty of care as parliament returns this week. The proposal is aimed at strengthening protections for Australian social media users, particularly children and other vulnerable groups.
Users Could Be Allowed to Turn Off Social Media Algorithms
One of the key measures under consideration would require major social media platforms to give users the ability to switch off algorithms that determine what appears in their feeds.
Under such a system, users could instead choose to see content only from friends, accounts and groups they actively follow.
The government is also considering tougher requirements for platforms to identify problematic or illegal material more effectively.
Labor argues that these changes could help reduce exposure to content that reinforces harmful stereotypes or behaviours, including material linked to body image, women’s safety and child protection.
Platforms Could Face Fines Above $100 Million
The proposed digital duty of care could introduce penalties exceeding $100 million for serious breaches.
The eSafety commissioner and approved researchers could also receive expanded powers to examine whether major social media companies are meeting their obligations.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is expected to promote the proposal at the United Nations General Assembly in New York later this month.
Angus Taylor Raises Censorship Concerns
Speaking to News24 on Sunday, Taylor said the government should first address problems with its under-16 social media restrictions before introducing additional regulation.
“I think everyone’s very disappointed at the way the government has implemented the initiatives to stop young Australians from getting access to social media,” Taylor said.
He claimed the measures had resulted in only about a 4.4% reduction and argued that parents should have greater control over what their children are able to access online.
“We’ll wait and see this legislation. I’m deeply sceptical. I fear that this is just going to be an attempt by the government to censor social media,” he said.
Taylor also warned against giving the communications minister extensive discretion under the proposed legislation.
“I fear, given Labor and the minister’s past biases, that this will just be an attempt to censor the internet, and that’s not what we should be doing.”
Coalition Says Individual Choice Must Be Protected
Outgoing Liberal senator and shadow home affairs minister Jonno Duniam compared Labor’s proposal with its previously abandoned anti-misinformation legislation.
Duniam said users should be able to decide what content they consume and parents should have similar control over what their children see.
“Empowering individuals to make a choice about what they consume is absolutely where we should be at,” he said.
He told ABC TV that the Coalition could support the plan only if it does not unnecessarily restrict people’s rights and freedoms.
Duniam also suggested that Australia’s existing classification systems covering television, cinema and other forms of media could provide a useful starting point for future regulation.
Pauline Hanson Criticises Government Plan
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson has also opposed the proposal, arguing that the government should not decide what Australians are exposed to online.
“Australia should be moving away from government censorship, not building the Orwellian machinery for it,” Hanson wrote on social media last week.
With both the Coalition and One Nation expressing opposition, Labor would likely need support from the Greens for any legislation to pass the Senate.
Greens Push for Stronger Opt-In Model
The Greens have called for an opt-in approach rather than simply giving users the option to turn algorithms off.
The model, also supported by campaigner Chanel Contos, would require users to provide explicit consent before social media platforms could use algorithm-driven systems to determine the content appearing in their feeds.
Labor’s proposed digital duty of care could significantly change how social media platforms operate in Australia by giving users more control over algorithm-driven feeds and introducing tougher penalties for breaches.
However, concerns about censorship, government powers and individual freedoms are likely to dominate the parliamentary debate. With opposition from the Coalition and One Nation, support from the Greens may prove crucial if the legislation reaches the Senate.