CRA Fines Vancouver Realtor $103,785 Over False Principal Residence Claim
A Vancouver realtor has been fined nearly $104,000 after falsely claiming that a rental property was her principal residence in an attempt to avoid paying income tax.
For approximately five years, Thi Nhan Nguyen, also known as Lynn Nguyen, regularly collected mail from a Vancouver rental property despite not living there. The arrangement was intended to support her claim that the property qualified as her primary residence for tax purposes.
However, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) determined that the home was occupied by a tenant throughout Nguyen’s ownership.
On August 25, 2026, Nguyen was sentenced in British Columbia provincial court to a nine-month conditional sentence and ordered to pay a $103,785 fine. The fine was equal to the amount of income tax she had evaded.
Why the Principal Residence Exemption Matters
Canada’s principal residence exemption (PRE) allows eligible homeowners to avoid paying capital gains tax on some or all of the increase in value when selling their principal home.
It is one of the country’s most significant tax benefits for homeowners, but principal residence claims can also receive close attention from the CRA.
Nguyen’s case demonstrates why Canadians who own multiple properties need to maintain accurate records and ensure that a property genuinely qualifies before claiming the exemption.
How the False Principal Residence Claim Worked
Nguyen became the registered owner of the Vancouver residential property in April 2012 and sold her interest in the property in 2017.
During the entire five-year ownership period, a tenant occupied the home.
Despite this, Nguyen took steps to make the property appear to be her principal residence. These included using the rental property’s address for correspondence and regularly collecting mail delivered there.
When the property was disposed of, Nguyen sold a 50% interest to a purchaser while transferring the remaining 50% to a related party.
She did not report the transaction when filing her 2017 income tax return.
CRA Audit Uncovered Inconsistencies
CRA auditors began questioning Nguyen about the property and its disposition in 2017.
Through a representative, Nguyen continued maintaining that the Vancouver rental property had been her principal residence and provided misleading information supporting that position.
The matter remained within the court system for years before Nguyen eventually pleaded guilty to one count of tax evasion under Canada’s Income Tax Act.
She was ultimately fined $103,785 and received a nine-month conditional sentence.
Why Simply Owning a Property Does Not Make It a Principal Residence
The principal residence exemption is not based solely on property ownership or the address listed on official documents.
For a property to qualify, the homeowner or qualifying family members generally need to have actually lived there. The CRA uses the concept of a property being “ordinarily inhabited” when determining whether it can qualify as a principal residence.
Because Nguyen did not ordinarily live in the rental property while owning it, it could not be treated as her principal residence for tax purposes.
Property Sale Reporting Rules Changed Before the Sale
Canada strengthened its principal residence reporting requirements beginning with the 2016 tax year.
Since then, Canadians selling residential property are generally required to report the disposition, even when the entire gain qualifies for the principal residence exemption.
Homeowners claiming the exemption must provide the required information through Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND).
Failing to report a property sale or falsely designating a rental property as a principal residence can result in additional taxes, penalties and interest. Serious cases may also lead to criminal prosecution.
Tax Evasion Penalties Can Be Much Higher
Although Nguyen received a significant penalty, Canadian tax evasion laws allow for even greater consequences.
A person convicted of tax evasion can face a fine of up to 200% of the tax evaded and imprisonment of up to five years. These penalties can apply in addition to repayment of the outstanding tax and accumulated interest.
Nguyen’s case was not based on a single issue. CRA auditors identified several inconsistencies over time, including a long-term tenant occupying the property, an unreported disposition and correspondence linked to an address where Nguyen did not actually live.
What Canadian Landlords and Property Owners Should Know
Canadians who convert a principal residence into a rental property, or later convert a rental property into their home, have legitimate tax options available.
Section 45(2) and Section 45(3) elections under the Income Tax Act may help preserve principal residence treatment in certain genuine changes of use.
Property owners should also remember several important rules:
- A property generally needs to have been genuinely occupied by you or qualifying family members to receive principal residence treatment.
- The sale of residential property must generally be reported, including the sale of a principal residence.
- Principal residence information is reported through Schedule 3 and, where applicable, Form T2091(IND).
- Tax evasion penalties can reach 200% of the tax evaded and may include imprisonment for up to five years.
- CRA audits can examine records covering several years, allowing inconsistencies to build into a broader case.
- Sections 45(2) and 45(3) can provide legitimate tax treatment when the use of a property genuinely changes.
The Nguyen case highlights the risks of falsely claiming a rental property as a principal residence. Simply receiving mail or using a property’s address does not establish that someone actually lived there.
For Canadians who own multiple properties or change a home’s use between personal and rental purposes, properly reporting transactions and using available tax elections is considerably safer than attempting to create a misleading paper trail.