Lifetime ISA Withdrawal Penalty Hits 45,000 Savers More Than Once
Around 45,000 Lifetime ISA holders were charged more than once for accessing their savings early during the 2024/25 tax year, new HMRC figures reveal.
The data, obtained by savings app Plum through a Freedom of Information request, shows that affected savers paid an average of approximately £760 in cumulative charges during the year.
Most people facing repeated deductions paid less than £1,000. However, some incurred substantially larger costs, highlighting the financial consequences of withdrawing Lifetime ISA funds outside the scheme’s permitted circumstances.
What the latest HMRC figures show
According to the figures:
- Approximately 45,000 people made more than one withdrawal that attracted a charge in 2024/25.
- The average cumulative charge among these savers was around £760.
- Roughly 33,530 people paid combined charges of up to £999.
- Around 60 savers accumulated charges of £8,000 or more.
- A further 60 paid between £7,000 and £7,999.
- Among the 25 people with the largest cumulative charges, the average was approximately £11,000.
The numbers relate specifically to people who were charged multiple times during a single tax year. They are separate from the broader annual statistics covering everyone who made at least one unauthorised Lifetime ISA withdrawal. The Independent reported the FOI findings.
Why does a Lifetime ISA withdrawal trigger a 25% charge?
A Lifetime ISA, commonly known as a LISA, allows eligible people to save for their first home or later life.
Account holders can contribute up to £4,000 during each tax year until they turn 50. The government adds a 25% bonus, meaning someone contributing the full allowance can receive as much as £1,000 annually.
However, money normally cannot be withdrawn without a charge unless the account holder is:
- Purchasing a qualifying first home;
- Aged 60 or older; or
- Terminally ill with less than 12 months to live.
Withdrawals made for other reasons are described by HMRC as “unauthorised” and generally attract a 25% charge. This may include taking money out to pay bills, cover debts or manage an unexpected financial emergency. GOV.UK explains the current withdrawal rules.
How the withdrawal penalty can reduce your own savings
The 25% charge applies to the full amount withdrawn, including the government bonus. As a result, it does more than simply reclaim the bonus.
For example:
- A saver deposits £4,000.
- The government adds a £1,000 bonus.
- The account balance becomes £5,000, assuming no interest or investment growth.
- An unauthorised full withdrawal attracts a £1,250 charge.
- The saver receives £3,750.
The saver has therefore lost the £1,000 bonus and £250 of their original contribution. This represents an effective loss of 6.25% of the money they personally deposited.
Investment gains or losses can change the final calculation, but the 25% charge will still apply to the value withdrawn.
When can a Lifetime ISA be used to buy a home?
A charge-free first-home withdrawal must satisfy several conditions.
Under the current rules:
- The property must cost £450,000 or less.
- The account must have been open for at least 12 months from the first payment.
- The buyer must use a conveyancer or solicitor.
- The provider must send the money directly to the conveyancer.
- The purchase must generally involve a qualifying mortgage.
- The property must be intended as the buyer’s main residence.
The nationwide £450,000 property limit has attracted criticism because it has remained unchanged while home prices have risen, particularly in London and parts of south-east England.
Someone buying a first property above that limit cannot use their LISA without incurring the withdrawal charge, even if the money is being used for a deposit.
Total LISA withdrawal charges reached almost £119 million
The repeat-withdrawal figures follow a separate HMRC statistical release covering the 2025/26 tax year.
That data shows approximately 154,100 people made withdrawals that incurred a charge. The total value of the charges was almost £119 million.
During the same year, 99,750 account holders used LISA funds to purchase their first home. Their average property-purchase withdrawal was £15,407. HMRC published the figures in its 2026 annual savings statistics.
These totals suggest that many account holders are accessing relatively modest amounts before becoming eligible for a charge-free withdrawal. Possible reasons include changes in homeownership plans, financial hardship or an urgent need for accessible cash.
How savers can reduce the risk of paying a LISA charge
People considering a Lifetime ISA should think carefully about whether they may need the money before buying a home or reaching age 60.
Practical steps include:
Keep emergency savings separate
Money for unexpected bills, unemployment or essential repairs may be better kept in an easy-access savings account. This avoids having to withdraw from a LISA during a financial emergency.
Check the likely cost of your first home
If properties in the area where you expect to buy are already close to or above £450,000, consider the possibility that your purchase may not meet the LISA rules.
Transfer instead of withdrawing
People wishing to change LISA providers should use the official ISA transfer process. Withdrawing the money personally and then trying to redeposit it could trigger the charge and affect ISA allowances.
Review the account before making another withdrawal
Repeated partial withdrawals can produce repeated charges. Ask the provider for a calculation showing the charge and the amount you will receive before confirming the transaction.
Consider regulated financial advice
A LISA may be useful for some retirement savers, particularly self-employed people, but it is not necessarily a replacement for a workplace or personal pension. The most appropriate option depends on tax status, employer contributions and access needs.
Is the Lifetime ISA being replaced?
The government has consulted on introducing a new First Time Buyer ISA. Under the proposal, the government bonus would be paid when the saver purchases a qualifying home instead of being added throughout the life of the account.
This design would allow people whose circumstances change to withdraw their own money without a LISA-style penalty.
The consultation closed in August 2026, but the final launch date and key limits have not yet been confirmed. The government says the new account will eventually be offered in place of the LISA. Existing holders are expected to remain able to keep and contribute to their accounts under the relevant rules. HM Treasury’s consultation outlines the proposed replacement.
What current LISA holders should know
No immediate rule change has removed the existing 25% charge. Until a replacement product is formally introduced and legislation takes effect, current LISA holders should continue to follow the present withdrawal conditions.
Before taking money out, check:
- Whether the withdrawal qualifies for an exemption;
- The exact charge your provider will deduct;
- Whether an official transfer would meet your needs instead;
- Whether the withdrawal affects your future home-purchase plans; and
- Whether another source of emergency funding would cost less.
The government bonus remains a valuable benefit for people who can follow the rules. However, the latest figures demonstrate why a Lifetime ISA should not generally be treated as an ordinary easy-access savings account.
Information is accurate as of October 7, 2026, and is provided for general information rather than personal financial advice.